Asset manager Canuma Capital has reduced its exposure to paper real estate investment funds to zero, according to statements by partner Marcelo Vainstein reported in the press. The firm argues that the returns offered by Real Estate Receivables Certificates (CRIs) within these portfolios no longer compensate for the risks assumed, making traditional fixed-income instruments and physical property FIIs more efficient choices for institutional capital.
Why Did Canuma Capital Exit Paper Real Estate Funds?
Canuma Capital's decision reflects a direct rearrangement of the risk premium driven by interest rate levels. According to partner Marcelo Vainstein, the average return distributed by receivables vehicles does not provide an attractive surplus over government bonds or simple post-fixed fixed income, requiring investors to take on real estate credit risk without adequate yield compensation.
The firm used various methodologies to monitor the evolution of sector dividend yields over the past 24 months and concluded that market sentiment has shifted. Because interest rates remain elevated—as evidenced when Copom kept the Selic rate at 13.75% to contain inflationary expectations—the opportunity cost of holding private debt has risen substantially.
Lagging institutional net return compared to direct CDI after fund operational fees.
Inflation spreads have lost relative attractiveness compared to nominal CDI returns.
Real assets trading below replacement cost, offering potential capital appreciation.
How High Rates Squeezed Inflation-Linked and Post-Fixed Premiums
According to data presented by Vainstein, this disadvantage affects both inflation-linked and post-fixed funds. In IPCA-adjusted funds, the premium on debentures and CRIs traded at IPCA plus a fixed rate has lost its attractive edge against double-digit nominal rates offered by the CDI. Investors assume market volatility and long durations to receive cash flows that do not stand out substantially from credit-risk-free fixed income.
In the post-fixed credit fund segment, the bottleneck lies in the relationship between profitability and management fees. Canuma Capital points out that portfolios with high-grade (low default risk) and middle-grade credit profiles deliver gross returns that, after deducting the FII's management and custodial costs, result in yields close to 100 basis points below the CDI (roughly CDI minus 1%). For institutional investors, this spread makes the structure unviable.
Even in vehicles focused on high-yield credit (higher risk and higher rates), the firm believes current dividends do not cover the imminent risk of default in the current macroeconomic environment. This analysis aligns with market warnings about how high fixed-income interest rates increase default risks in structured and leveraged credit transactions.
Why Physical Property Funds Started Making More Sense Than Paper
After abandoning the credit segment, Canuma shifted its focus to physical real estate funds—a category that includes logistics warehouses, corporate office buildings, and shopping centers. The core logic behind this rotation is the asymmetry between price and net asset value (NAV). While paper funds are worth strictly the outstanding balance of the issued security, property funds hold physical real estate whose lease contracts continue to be adjusted for inflation.
When interest rates remain elevated for a prolonged period, physical real estate fund units often trade at significant discounts in the secondary market. Investors can acquire stakes in high-quality properties trading well below their reconstruction cost. As a result, alongside rental distributions, buyers lock in significant potential unit appreciation for when the monetary cycle eventually turns downward.
Other analysts and research houses see similar nuances in this asset class breakdown. While positions such as BB Investimentos' assessment of KNCR11 highlight the defensive cushioning of post-fixed credit FIIs during uncertain times, active equity and real estate fund managers view the risk-reward profile of physical property as superior to credit over the medium term.
Should Retail Investors Follow the Manager and Sell CRI FIIs?
Retail investors should not automatically copy institutional moves. Institutional funds and asset managers face mandate restrictions, rigid benchmark-outperformance targets, and different tax accounting rules than individual investors. For retail investors, distributions from FIIs remain tax-exempt, whereas traditional fixed-income securities taxed on a regressive income tax scale face deductions at the source.
Furthermore, not all paper funds operate at the same profitability level. An individual analysis of a fund's portfolio reveals whether its assets are protected against defaults, as demonstrated in market assessments regarding ARXD11 and the credit risk of the Fragnani CRI, where unit discounts and collateral coverage levels determine the true attractiveness of the investment.
If you hold receivables funds in your portfolio, the manager's warning does not signal a blanket liquidation, but rather the need to evaluate three points: what your real net yield is compared to the current CDI, the credit quality of the underlying borrowers, and whether you are overexposed to private credit at a time when sovereign fixed-income instruments offer high yields.
What to Monitor in Your Real Estate Fund Portfolio Moving Forward
The thesis presented by Canuma Capital requires continuous monitoring of financial market signals and the financial health of real estate debt issuers. To manage your exposure intelligently, follow this checklist:
Compare the FII Yield to the Net CDI — Check whether the dividend distributed by your low-risk paper FII comfortably outperforms the net return of the CDI (accounting for equivalent taxes on traditional fixed-income investments).
Examine Vacancy Rates and P/NAV Ratios for Physical FIIs — Monitor whether the physical real estate funds on your watchlist continue to trade at discounts to net asset value with stable occupancy rates.
Review CRI Management Reports — Pay close attention to underlying collateral, debt-service coverage ratios (LTV), and any payment delays from borrowers in your paper funds.
The Verdict: Canuma's Move Reflects Opportunity Cost
Canuma Capital's decision highlights that with high CDI rates, taking on private credit risk without adequate compensation loses strategic sense for large allocators. For retail investors, the move serves as a market signal: real estate credit demands extreme selectivity, and discounted physical property funds are beginning to offer an asymmetric profile that is drawing institutional capital.