Nord Research recently questioned, in a video by analyst Marília Fontes, whether it still makes sense to send money abroad with the U.S. dollar above R$ 5.80 or if buying at such elevated levels would be a mistake. Based on our calculations, the answer depends entirely on your objective. For long-term portfolio diversification, yes, provided you do it gradually. As a short-term speculative bet that the dollar will keep climbing, it has become expensive: simply to break even on transaction costs, the greenback needs to rise another 4.5%.
Is It Worth Sending Money Abroad With the Dollar Near R$ 6?
For investors with zero offshore exposure, allocating a portion of your portfolio abroad makes sense, but not all at once. The commercial dollar closed Thursday (Nov. 19) at R$ 5.9344, and rushing to hedge your portfolio is proving costly: today's price already reflects a substantial amount of market fear.
Nord's video began with a clear observation: the dollar crossed R$ 5.80 following the election and has once again become a major source of concern for investors. Marília Fontes is a founding partner at the research firm, a fixed-income analyst, and the author of the book "Renda Fixa não é Fixa" (Fixed Income Isn't Fixed). The summary released by Nord does not give away her final conclusion. What is documented, however, is what she wrote on October 1, before the first round, arguing that investors should never wager their portfolios on the outcome of a tight race: "I lost a lot in 2014 by betting on a close election." Rushing into dollars now, after a sharp rally, is also an election-driven bet—only placed after the results are in.
To evaluate this quantitatively, one must first look at the magnitude of the rally.
How Much Has the Dollar Gained Since the Election, and Why?
On the eve of the runoff election on October 23, the commercial dollar stood at R$ 5.0377. Through the close on November 19, the exchange rate surged 17.8% according to our calculations. That aligns closely with the "roughly 20%" cited by fund managers speaking to the financial daily Valor. While checking weekend prices is helpful, you can track daily updates on our dollar quote and fair value page.
The currency's advance unfolded in two distinct legs. The first was the immediate reaction to the election outcome. The second began in mid-November, marked by six consecutive trading sessions of gains. On November 19, even a US$ 1 billion spot market intervention by the Central Bank of Brazil failed to halt the dollar's momentum. Market reports differ on historical comparisons: some note this as the highest level since January 2025, while others point to April 2025. In either case, the exchange rate is sitting at its highest level in at least 19 months.
Domestic politics is not the only driver. According to InfoMoney, foreign investors purchased nearly US$ 17 billion in FX derivatives on the B3 exchange following the runoff. Fiscal uncertainties and U.S. interest rate dynamics also weigh heavily: Cristiano Oliveira, an economist at Banco Pine, notes that the Federal Reserve raised rates in September and that the U.S. yield curve began pricing in an additional 0.75 percentage point in hikes. Prior to the election, Goldman Sachs highlighted that the exchange rate would depend less on the specific candidate and more on subsequent economic policy, estimating that R$ 4.80 represented fair value absent a political risk premium. Right now, the market is pricing in that full risk premium—and then some.
So, what does this mean in real terms for someone remitting funds abroad today?
How Much More Does It Cost to Send R$ 10,000 Abroad?
The screen rate is never what you actually pay. For wire transfers to your own international account, Brazil levies a 3.5% IOF financial transactions tax under Decree 12,499 of 2025, and every provider charges an FX spread on top of the commercial rate. In the comparison below, we assume a 1% spread, reflecting typical digital platform pricing. In September, Central Bank data showed the total cost to transfer US$ 1,000 varied by as much as R$ 602 between the cheapest and most expensive institutions.
| 10/23 (pre-runoff) | 11/19 | |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial dollar | R$ 5.04 | R$ 5.93 |
| With 1% spread (estimate) | R$ 5.09 | R$ 5.99 |
| With 3.5% IOF (effective cost) | R$ 5.27 | R$ 6.20 |
| Dollars purchased with R$ 10,000 | ≈ US$ 1,899 | ≈ US$ 1,612 |
The bottom line tells the story: the exact same R$ 10,000 buys approximately 287 fewer dollars today than it did a month ago. There is another frictional cost investors often overlook. With an effective all-in cost near R$ 6.20, the dollar must rise roughly 4.5% above today's commercial spot rate merely to break even. If the real strengthens back to R$ 5.50—its post-election level—an investor entering all at once faces an immediate loss of roughly 11% in local currency terms. If the dollar reaches R$ 6.50, the gain is only about 5%. The downside risk currently outweighs the upside potential, which is why panicking into foreign currency is costly.
Why, then, are major wealth management firms expanding their foreign allocations right now?
What Asset Managers Are Doing—and Why It Isn't a Reason to Rush
According to Valor, demand for international transfers accelerated following the runoff, despite the less favorable exchange rate. Somma Investimentos, which manages R$ 20 billion, raised its recommended offshore allocation from 20% to 35% of client portfolios, with targets reaching up to 50% for family offices with more than R$ 300 million in assets. TAG Investimentos, with R$ 18 billion under management, increased its exposure from 30% to 40%. Wealth managers report that clients frequently express fears of capital controls or remittance freezes under a fourth Lula presidential term. For individual investors, however, the critical detail is the execution: asset managers recommend deploying capital gradually across a six-month window rather than sending a lump sum all at once.
- Holding capital abroad provides structural protection against Brazil risk denominated in reais—and that risk did not disappear with the currency's depreciation.
- Dollar-cost averaging via monthly installments smooths out the entry price: if the real appreciates, subsequent tranches will be cheaper.
- Higher U.S. interest rates and institutional derivative flows continue to provide fundamental support for the greenback.
- With an effective purchase price near R$ 6.20, deploying an entire allocation at once requires substantial further dollar appreciation just to break even.
- The exchange rate already prices in far more than the political risk premium estimated by Goldman Sachs prior to the vote. Any credible positive fiscal signal could prompt a rapid rebound in the real.
- Domestically, double-digit yields on the Selic benchmark rate generate low-risk income without currency volatility while you space out your international remittances.
Fear of government expropriation is a political narrative, not an investment calculation, and investors acting purely on sentiment often end up buying at peak market distress. For those who prefer not to open an offshore account, dollar exposure can be acquired directly on the B3 through ETFs and BDRs without paying the remittance IOF. We previously broke down the opposing case in our analysis of Vinland's rationale for betting against the dollar.
What Happens to Capital Left in Brazil?
The same macroeconomic strain that pushed the dollar higher also drove Brazilian interest rate futures upward and pulled the domestic equity market down. Investors choosing to wait are not sitting idle: local fixed-rate and inflation-linked bonds are currently offering higher real yields, as detailed in our guide on investing through Tesouro Direto after the election. In equities, research firm Gavekal pointed out that an election-driven selloff could create compelling entry points, an argument we explored in our piece on why Gavekal views Brazilian equities as a buy on weakness.
If you currently have no international investments, establish a target allocation—such as 10% to 20% of your total liquid net worth—and break it into six regular monthly purchases. If you already hold a dollar allocation, avoid selling impulsively; recent market moves demonstrate that your hedge is doing its job. However, if your goal was to speculate on short-term currency appreciation, that rally has largely played out. At R$ 5.93 per dollar, the potential upside no longer justifies the downside risk.
Our verdict: Nord asked the right question, and the solution is neither "move everything abroad today" nor "wait on the sidelines indefinitely." With effective transaction costs near R$ 6.20, sending all your money at once is a high-risk bet that the dollar will keep surging. Staggering your purchases over several months—precisely what leading wealth managers advise—turns a speculative bet into structural diversification. And long-term diversification remains as essential as ever.