The 11.3% CBS Rate and the Senate Showdown With Dario Durigan Relevance4,0
Intermediate PTENES

The 11.3% CBS Rate and the Senate Showdown With Dario Durigan

The Finance Minister appeared before the CAE to defend a rate that exceeded congressional expectations and reignited the dispute over exemptions.

Finance Minister Dario Durigan appeared before the Senate's Economic Affairs Committee (CAE) on Tuesday to defend an 11.3% rate for the CBS and assert that fiscal consolidation must be gradual. The federal levy surpassed what lawmakers expected and reopened the dispute over who will foot the bill for the exemptions granted during the tax reform rollout.

Why did the 11.3% CBS rate catch the Senate by surprise?

Because the percentage exceeded the estimates that Congress took for granted during the initial rounds of voting. According to Senator Eduardo Braga, the bill's rapporteur, the chamber was surprised by the level calculated for the Contribution on Goods and Services (CBS), which will take effect by replacing PIS and Cofins. Because the tax makes up only the federal leg of the new Dual VAT, lawmakers' reading is that when added to the state and municipal IBS, it could push standard taxation close to or beyond 28%.

Faced with questions, Durigan argued that the percentage did not stem from an arbitrary decision by the economic team, but rather from the math imposed by tax breaks. In the explanation brought to the CAE, the minister pointed out that every benefit, reduced rate, and preferential regime inserted into the bill requires raising the levy on sectors that remained under the general rule in order to keep federal revenue stable.

This friction does not arise in a vacuum. As we noted in our coverage of when the rapporteur rejected the CBS rate, Parliament resists absorbing the political fallout of endorsing a double-digit federal tax without shifting the blame back to the Executive branch.

“The only path is a gradual adjustment that respects social spending, but without a doubt, without denialism, with the need for us to advance in this improvement of public accounts.”Dario Durigan, Finance Minister, at a Senate CAE public hearing

What is the Ministry calling a gradual adjustment?

The Finance Minister classified the current set of budget measures as a "first step" and rejected the idea of abrupt fiscal shocks. According to Durigan, balancing the accounts must proceed at a progressive pace, preserving social spending while maintaining the technical rigor needed to contain the trajectory of public debt.

The central thesis presented to senators is that fiscal discipline should not be treated as an isolated accounting trophy. In the minister's words, the surplus is an indispensable tool to unlock monetary easing in the country. By curbing the expansion of sovereign debt, the government seeks to create technical room for the Central Bank to lower the benchmark interest rate, which consequently lowers financing costs for both the National Treasury and private companies.

At the same time, Durigan openly advocated for reviewing special regimes and tax exemptions as early as 2028. For the head of the economic portfolio, this scheduled reassessment will be the only sustainable way to shrink the CBS percentage without compromising public revenue commitments tied to fiscal targets.

Ministry's Thesis 11.3% CBS Rate

Represents the sum needed to neutralize the hundreds of special regimes granted by the Legislature itself.

Senate Pressure Global Ceiling

Lawmakers fear that combining the CBS with the state IBS will exceed 28%, causing severe friction with services and retail.

Who wins and who loses with the new tax calibration?

The tax reform bill does not impact businesses listed on the B3 uniformly. The transition to the new model creates clear winners in heavy industry and exporters, while the service sector and tax-exempt consumption face compressed operating margins.

Companies with long production chains and capital-intensive operations are able to accumulate and fully credit the tax paid in previous stages, shedding residual tax cumulation. Conversely, companies whose main cost lies in payroll—such as technology, private healthcare, education, and leasing—generate little tax credit and will face a nominal rate substantially higher than the former 9.25% PIS/Cofins.

It is worth noting that Congress was already politically modulating the transition schedule. As we pointed out when the CBS gained an extra 30-day window for final settlement, the final dates and safeguards remain open and depend on the outcome of regulatory text negotiations.

Segment CBS Mechanism Impact on Margins Market Outlook
Manufacturing Industry Extensive use of input and machinery credits Positive Gains competitiveness by eliminating tax residues
Services and Consultancies Costs concentrated in salaries, with little tax credit Negative Pressure to pass costs to clients or lose margin
Retail and Broad Consumption End of tax cumulation, but heavier final rate Neutral to Neutral-Low Price elasticity of each product will determine the outcome
Exporters and Commodities Total exemption on outbound goods Neutral-High Maintain constitutional immunity with credit refunds

Parallel to the discussions on consumption, the progress of budget matters is moving forward in a tense climate. Last week, the baseline text of the fiscal adjustment passed the Senate, but resistance to structural spending containment measures continues to keep analysts skeptical about how quickly mandatory expenses will fall.

What This Means for Investors

The most immediate effect is on the future interest rate curve and risk appetite. If the 11.3% CBS rate is confirmed to cover the fiscal gap, companies dependent on domestic consumption and services will have to revise earnings projections for 2027 and 2028. In fixed income, the Ministry's insistence on a "gradual" adjustment without aggressive spending cuts sustains premiums on long-term IPCA+ government bonds, as the market remains hesitant to price in a swift Selic rate-cutting cycle.

What to monitor from here on?

The technical discussion in the CAE is just the first in a series of battles between the Ministry and congressional leaders. Investors should monitor the government's ability to sustain these fiscal assumptions amid the processing of legislative amendments, which still threaten to water down projected revenues.

1

The voting on amendments in the CAE and Plenary — watch whether senators will attempt to impose a strict legal safeguard preventing the CBS from exceeding a fixed ceiling before 2027.

2

FX and DI interest rate sentiment — verify whether doubts surrounding fiscal tightening and the preservation of social spending will continue to pressure the U.S. dollar and the long-term yield curve.

3

The review of special regimes for 2028 — follow which heavyweight B3 sectors manage to shield their tax incentives and which have benefits stripped away in the final calibration.

Verdict: The 11.3% rate starkly exposes the cost of political bargains made during the tax reform: without real cuts to exemptions, the standard rate rises. For investors, Durigan's message that the adjustment will be strictly gradual confirms that monetary policy will have no easy path to easing rates in the short term, requiring heightened caution with leveraged companies and sectors with low pricing power.