What the IFI Said About the Fiscal Adjustment Approved by the Senate Relevance4,0
Intermediate PTENES

What the IFI Said About the Fiscal Adjustment Approved by the Senate

The IFI warns that 70% of the potential relief depends on uncertain revenues and calls for a structural plan by December.

The Independent Fiscal Institution (IFI) warned on Thursday that the package approved by the Senate the day before does not balance the 2027 budget—and that without a structural plan presented before the end of December, the primary result could fall R$ 122 billion below the fiscal target floor.

What Did the IFI Say About the Fiscal Adjustment Approved by the Senate?

The diagnosis from directors Marcus Pestana and Alexandre Andrade, published in the November Fiscal Monitoring Report (RAF) on November 19, is that Supplementary Bill PLP 299/2026 marks the "closing of the cycle" for the 2023–2026 economic policy—rather than the starting point for Lula's fourth term. In other words, the IFI views the bill as a normalization of commitments made by the current administration, not a solution to the challenges inherited by the next government. The core text was approved in the Senate by a 69-to-2 vote on Wednesday, November 18.

The potential improvement in the 2027 primary result carried by the bill ranges between R$ 45.1 billion and R$ 56.1 billion—a wider interval than XP's calculation, which estimated only R$ 38.3 billion in permanent effect. However, the IFI is not concerned with the upper end of that potential. The real issue is the quality supporting that figure.

Of the R$ 45.1 billion to R$ 56.1 billion in primary improvement, only R$ 19.5 billion represents recurring gains with structural predictability. The remaining 70% of the potential—between R$ 32.3 billion and R$ 37.8 billion—depends entirely on tax collection: restrictions on tax credit offsets, cuts to tax breaks, and changes to healthcare spending whose realization pace is uncertain and, in part, subject to legal challenges.

The fiscal weight of this fragility is clear in the public debt trajectory: in September 2026, debt stood at 82.9% of GDP, and even with all PLP measures realized as projected, it would reach 118% of GDP by 2034. Without the package, the projection would hit 121%—a 3-percentage-point difference that, in absolute terms, represents hundreds of billions in debt-rollover costs.

What Has Lula Committed Since Submitting the 2027 Budget?

While Congress debated the adjustment, the government moved in the opposite direction. Since submitting the 2027 Budget to Congress, executive branch statements have increased projected expenditures by R$ 40.1 billion and cut revenue estimates by R$ 6.4 billion. The R$ 149.4 billion supplementary credit approved by Congress in November illustrates the sheer scale of the short-term pressure the adjustment would need to absorb. According to the IFI, the largest shares of these newly committed expenses include:

Bolsa Família (15.04% adjustment)R$ 22.7 billion
Pé-de-Meia expansionR$ 9.6 billion
End of online betting (revenue loss)R$ 5.3 billion
Desenrola 3.0R$ 5.0 billion

Adding the R$ 40.1 billion in new expenses to the R$ 6.4 billion drop in revenue estimates, the fiscal pressure added by the government itself reaches R$ 46.5 billion—an amount that exceeds the lower limit of the PLP's potential and nearly consumes its entire upper bound. In other words, the adjustment covers most of the hole the government created after submitting the budget. What remains to genuinely balance the books is scarce.

What the Fiscal Package Delivers—and What Is Still Missing

The IFI separated the impact on the primary result from the breathing room that the PLP effectively opens up within the spending cap. These are distinct issues, and the latter matters most for budget execution:

Primary improvementR$ 45.1 bn – R$ 56.1 bn

Total potential of PLP 299/2026, according to the IFI. The government estimates up to R$ 60 billion.

Revenue-dependent70% of the adjustment

Between R$ 32.3 billion and R$ 37.8 billion rely on tax receipts with uncertain or contestable realization.

Uncovered expensesR$ 20.1 billion

Even with the package, room under the 2027 spending cap remains insufficient to accommodate new expenses.

The concrete problem lies in the cap on discretionary spending. Under the PLP, this limit would drop from R$ 138 billion to R$ 98 billion in 2027. However, the IFI estimates that a minimum of R$ 103.5 billion is required just to keep basic public operations running. The spending cap would fall R$ 5.5 billion below the operational floor. The package opens up only R$ 8.8 billion in spending room—less than half of the R$ 20.1 billion the government still needs to accommodate.

This context explains why the IFI considers PLP 299/2026 insufficient not only in terms of its primary result, but as a budgetary management tool for 2027. The R$ 80 billion agreement announced in November created expectations that the approved instrument simply does not deliver to the same degree.

What Primary Result Does the IFI Project for 2027?

"Supplementary Bill No. 299/2026 should be understood not as the inaugural act of President Lula's fourth term, but rather as the closing of the economic policy cycle for 2023–2026. President Lula is expected to announce, still in December, a strategic, consistent, solid, and credible flight plan."Marcus Pestana and Alexandre Andrade, IFI Directors — November RAF, November 19, 2026

Economic growth serves as an aggravating factor in the 2027 projection. The budget was built on a projected 2.5% expansion in GDP. The IFI estimates 1.8%, with a downward bias. Market projections gathered in the Focus report point to 1.02%. Slower growth means lower tax collection—making the 70% of the adjustment that relies on revenue even more vulnerable if GDP comes in below expectations. This represents the embedded risk that the IFI characterizes as "uncertain."

In a scenario without a credible additional plan, the IFI outlines the following outlook for 2027. The fiscal target set by the fiscal framework centers on a R$ 73.2 billion surplus, with a floor at R$ 36.6 billion:

With a structural plan by DecemberTarget remains achievable

If the government announces concrete, recurring additional measures (rather than uncertain revenues) within December, and PLP 299 passes the Chamber without being watered down, the 2027 result can stay above the R$ 36.6 billion surplus floor. This also requires tax collection to materialize as projected.

Without additional measuresProjected deficit of R$ 86.1 billion

Campaign promises weigh fully, uncertain revenues fail to materialize at the expected pace, and GDP falls short of the budgeted figures. The IFI projects an R$ 86.1 billion deficit—R$ 122.7 billion below the fiscal target floor and R$ 159 billion below the center.

What Does This Mean for Fixed-Income and FII Investors?

The transmission channel from fiscal policy to investors is the Selic rate. Elevated fiscal risk keeps the benchmark rate higher for longer, because the Central Bank requires a higher risk premium to anchor inflation when public finances are under pressure. The gap between the budget's GDP growth (2.5%) and the market's forecast (1.02%) also matters: weaker growth shrinks the tax base, reducing the probability that 70% of the adjustment will materialize—and leaving the Selic without the justification of genuinely improved public accounts.

For Brazilian real estate fund (FII) investors, the mechanism is direct: a higher Selic rate for longer raises the discount rate used to price the funds, compressing unit values—especially among brick-and-mortar funds with IPCA-indexed leases. For holders of Tesouro IPCA+ inflation-linked bonds, the fiscal risk scenario sustains high real yields: long-term protection remains attractive, but demands tolerance for short-term price volatility while uncertainty persists.

What This Means for Fixed-Income or FII Investors

The adjustment approved by the Senate yesterday does not guarantee a faster decline in the Selic rate in 2027. The real test is the plan the government must present by December: if it includes concrete, recurring measures, market perception will shift. If it arrives as a generic announcement or relies primarily on tax revenue, the risk premium on the yield curve will not recede. Until this scenario resolves, long-term fixed-rate bonds and IPCA+ notes remain the most defensive entry points for navigating fiscal uncertainty.

1

Lula's December fiscal plan — The IFI expects the president and incoming ministers of finance and planning to announce structural and recurring measures by year-end. Key signal to monitor: whether the announced measures reduce the revenue-dependent component or reinforce permanent spending bases.

2

PLP 299/2026 in the Chamber of Deputies — The text approved by the Senate must still clear the Chamber. Amendments that reduce the adjustment potential or increase uncovered spending will widen the existing R$ 20.1 billion hole in the spending cap.

3

Realization of 2027 revenues — 70% of the adjustment (R$ 32.3 billion to R$ 37.8 billion) depends on tax collection. Monitoring begins in the first bimester, when the government publishes its revenue and expenditure evaluation report. If GDP comes in below 1.8%, the risk of failing to realize this component increases.