Lula Says Financial Market Won't Teach Him How to Govern—As House Votes on Fiscal Package Monday
URGENTE PTENES

Lula Says Financial Market Won't Teach Him How to Govern—As House Votes on Fiscal Package Monday

On a Saturday livestream, Brazil's president attacked financial markets while defending a R$ 15 billion cut to tax exemptions, ahead of a key House vote on Monday (23).

President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva went live Saturday morning to defend the government’s fiscal package while setting a combative tone for the week ahead, asserting that the financial sector will not teach him how to govern Brazil. With the U.S. dollar trading at R$ 5.91 and the House of Representatives scheduled to vote on PLP 299/2026 on Monday (Nov. 23), the president's contentious stance extends the risk premium that has pressured the exchange rate and long-term interest rates since the start of the month.

What Lula Said—And What Unsettled Markets

The president hosted a livestream with federal deputy André Janones (Rede-MG) on Saturday morning, Nov. 21, to build support for PLP 299/2026—the fiscal adjustment bill passed 69–2 by the Senate on Wednesday (Nov. 18). What drew market attention was not the defense of the package itself, but the framing: Lula launched a direct attack on "Faria Lima"—Brazil's financial hub—claiming that financial market executives are driven purely by profit rather than national interest.

"The financial system is not going to teach me how to run the country. I cannot accept Faria Lima constantly questioning the seriousness of this government."Lula, livestream on 11/21/2026

The president also stated that corporate tax exemptions in Brazil exceed R$ 600 billion, and that the package aims to claw back R$ 15 billion without hitting small businesses under the Simples Nacional regime or micro-entrepreneurs (MEIs). He denied any cuts to mandatory spending floors for health, education, or the minimum wage: "Under no circumstances will a single cent be taken from the poor to balance the budget," he declared. Clarifying his scope, he added: "This was not a structural fiscal reform. It was an adjustment so that we can maintain governance over the budget."

What PLP 299/2026 Actually Proposes

The bill amends the fiscal framework—Complementary Law 200/2023—on four distinct fronts. The measure most frequently cited by Lula is an across-the-board 20% cut to tax incentives, reducing exemptions by R$ 15 billion. The other three measures are technical, yet equally vital to the magnitude of the overall adjustment:

Tax exemption cuts (20% across-the-board)R$ 15.0 billion
Tax credit utilization limitsR$ 12.8–18.3 billion
Enhanced budget impoundment mechanismsR$ 12.8–18.3 billion
Cap on Reidi (infrastructure incentives)R$ 4.5 billion

Taking the midpoints of these ranges, the government projects a total positive impact of R$ 33 billion to R$ 54 billion on the primary balance. On paper, it is a significant figure. However, as noted in our coverage of the market's initial reaction to the fiscal package in November, brokerages such as XP estimated that only R$ 38.3 billion represents a permanent effect. The remainder relies on temporary revenues, future collection, or triggers that only activate if primary targets are at risk.

Why Markets View the Package as Insufficient

Market criticism is directed less at the individual measures and more at what they reveal about the government's approach to fiscal balance. Two of the four pillars in PLP 299/2026 rely on revenue expansion—raising tax burdens on corporations by curbing exemptions and limiting tax credits. The other two are conditional: budget impoundment is triggered only when there is a risk of missing fiscal targets, while the cap on Reidi represents a marginal tweak to an infrastructure tax incentive scheme.

Brazil's structural fiscal challenges stem from mandatory spending—specifically Social Security, civil service payroll, and court-ordered debt payments (precatórios)—which expand automatically regardless of fiscal targets. An adjustment that relies primarily on revenue collection provides short-term relief rather than a durable solution. That is why, despite the bill advancing in Congress, the U.S. dollar reached R$ 5.93 on Thursday (Nov. 19), forcing the Central Bank to sell US$ 1 billion in spot reserves to curb exchange rate volatility, while the Ibovespa dropped 3.53% for the week—as detailed in our analysis on why the dollar surged near R$ 6. Long-term interest rate futures also moved higher, reflecting markets pricing in the risk that fiscal shortfalls will reemerge by 2028.

As Nomad strategist Reebecca Nossig observed: "The persistence of a strong dollar, even as the fiscal package moves forward in Congress, indicates that market participants remain defensive and continue to seek safe-haven assets." In short, PLP 299/2026 has failed to convince investors that underlying fiscal imbalances are resolved.

What Lula’s Speech Changes for Market Perception

Lula did not alter any specific details of PLP 299/2026 during Saturday’s livestream; the bill moves to the House floor in the exact form approved by the Senate. What his statements change is market perception regarding the government's willingness to pursue further spending restraint.

By framing the debate as an attempt by the financial sector to dictate policy, the signal to institutional investors and capital allocators is that any future fiscal correction will likely be forced by economic pressure rather than driven proactively by the executive branch. This dynamic suggests that foreign exchange rates and long-term interest rates may remain under upward pressure for longer to force policy shifts. As noted in our breakdown of tax incentive cuts tied to the 2027 fiscal target, the administration recognized that revenue measures alone were insufficient to close the structural deficit, yet chose that path anyway. Saturday's remarks confirm that choice was deliberate rather than temporary.

What the House Decides on Monday

Monday's House vote on PLP 299/2026 represents the next major catalyst for local interest rate curves and currency markets. The Senate-approved text faces pushback from two fronts: left-wing factions seeking explicit safeguards for social spending, and center-right parties attempting to scale back limitations on corporate tax credits—the provision raising the greatest concern among business leaders.

House passes bill without amendmentsPartial relief

The Senate text passes in full. Markets view it as a bare minimum; the real may strengthen modestly, though high U.S. interest rates will continue to limit downside for the dollar.

Amendments dilute key measuresRenewed pressure

Floor amendments strip or weaken the cut to tax exemptions or credit limits. Markets view this as a setback, leading to dollar strength, higher long-term yields, and renewed pressure on Central Bank reserves.

What This Means for Investors

Fixed Income: As long as fiscal uncertainty persists, long-term yields will remain elevated. Inflation-linked bonds, such as long-dated NTN-Bs (IPCA+), continue to offer attractive real yields for investors seeking purchasing power protection. FIIs (Brazilian Real Estate Funds): High discount rates continue to weigh on fund valuations. Paper and credit-focused FIIs (fundos de papel) remain better positioned relative to equity real estate funds (fundos de tijolo), as their yield payouts track prevailing interest rates. Equities: Volatility in interest rates and foreign exchange places pressure on highly leveraged companies and domestic consumer-facing sectors reliant on credit availability. Conversely, exporters and commodity producers retain natural downside protection from a weaker real. Currency: The real currently trades with a elevated risk premium—our models suggest the dollar sits above levels justified purely by external fundamentals. However, political friction and Congressional uncertainty will delay any valuation normalization.

1

Monday House Vote: Watch whether floor amendments alter the R$ 15 billion tax exemption cut or corporate credit limits. Dilution of these revenue measures would reduce the total fiscal package size and trigger negative market reaction.

2

Monday FX Close: A exchange rate closing above R$ 5.90 indicates the market views the vote outcome as disappointing; a move below R$ 5.80 would signal the start of a unwind in the fiscal risk premium built up this month.

3

Long-End Yield Curve: Real yields on NTN-B 2035 bonds trading above 7.00% reflect continued market skepticism regarding fiscal convergence by 2027. This rate serves as the clearest benchmark of institutional investor sentiment.